A baby shower is a time to celebrate the mom-to-be and show her how much she means to her friends and family. While themes and menus may vary at baby showers, a baby shower cake has become a customary part of the festivities.
If you’re responsible for selecting the baby shower cake, you have an important job to do. Everyone looks forward to eating the cake, and you want to make sure the one you buy is a tasty success.
In this article, we will offer a few tips on how to choose a baby shower cake design, baby shower cake ideas and where to order baby shower cakes.
1. Figure Out the Guest List
Before you think about baby shower cake decorations, you should consider how many people you need to serve. Baby shower cakes prices depend a lot on the size of the cake.
- For 8 to 12 guests, a round baby shower cake or 1/8th sheet cake is usually the right size.
- For 13 to 24 guests, a quarter sheet cake will be a good solution.
- For 25 to 50 guests, half sheet cakes and 2-tier baby shower cakes are usually enough food.
- For more than 50 guests, you’ll need to look at baby shower sheet cakes or 3-tier baby shower cakes.
2. Set Up a Budget for Baby Shower Cake
Another major consideration is the budget or how much you have to spend on a cake for the baby shower. Round small baby shower cakes are usually the least expensive, while multi-tier cakes are generally the most expensive. A baby shower sheet cake will fall somewhere in-between.
Your location and how elaborate your design is will also affect the cost of your baby shower cake. Knowing up front how much you can afford to spend will help you focus on designs that are the right fit for you.
Once you have determined the number of guests, you’ll know the basic cost of the cake. You can then consider baby shower cake decorations, options and designs.
3. Choose Where to Shop
Next, you’ll want to figure out what type of store to shop at for baby shower cakes. There are three main options:
- Discount Cakes. Walmart baby shower designs, Costco baby shower cakes, and Sams Club baby shower cakes all fall under this category. They’re usually the lowest priced options.
- Grocery Store Cakes. Cakes from your local grocery store’s bakery are usually mid-priced. Examples include Publix baby shower cakes, Kroger baby shower cakes, Safeway baby shower cakes, HEB baby shower cakes and Albertsons baby shower cakes.
- Independent Bakeries. Small independent bakeries are generally the most expensive places to buy baby shower cakes from.
You can check out our list of the best places to buy baby shower cakes for more information about top stores.
4. Start Comparing Designs
Baby shower cakes come in all sorts of designs. You can opt for a simple design, with a couple of decorations and a cake topper. This is a good option especially if you don’t know the gender of the baby yet. If you do know the gender, you can personalize the baby shower cake even further. Most bakeries offer baby shower cakes for girls and baby shower cakes for boys. Customization options can range from simply choosing the color of the icing, to adding unique baby shower decorations and messages.
You can use our articles to research baby shower cake ideas, and see what each bakery has on offer. Most bakeries have their own unique baby shower cake designs to choose from. You can also consider opting for a more novel treat, such as a baby shower cupcake cake.
5. Remember the Mom-to-Be
As you look at the designs, be sure to keep the guest of honor in mind. Is she having a boy or a girl, or is she keeping the baby’s gender a surprise? Does she have a classic or modern taste? A funny or quirky sense of humor? Try to look at the cake designs from her perspective.
6. Keep Your Theme in Mind
Some baby showers have special themes, such as storks or lambs. If you’re having a special theme shower, you can look for baby shower cakes that will match its design. Of course, it’s not a rule that you have to tie the cake to the theme. You’re free to have whatever type of design appeals to you, fits your budget and suits the mom to be.
7. Select the Cake Flavor
Once you have decided which of the many baby shower cakes that are available is right for your party, you can begin designing your cake by selecting the cake flavor.
Chocolate, vanilla, and marble or a combination of two flavors are the most popular options. Some bakeries may have other flavors like carrot cake or red velvet. If you’re not sure what the guest of honor likes, it’s usually best to stick to a standard flavor.
8. Choose the Icing
With some baby shower cakes, you may get your choice of icing. Buttercream is the most popular option, as it is sweet and tasty and easy to work with. Sweeter whipped frosting and richer cream cheese frosting are also offered by some bakeries.Choosing the icing color is also the easiest way to customize your baby shower cake design. You can go for the traditional pink for girl baby shower cakes, or blue for boy baby shower cakes. But you can also try something a bit more interesting, like a fresh green, or yellow.
If your party is going to be outdoors and you don’t have any way to refrigerate the cake, you may want to look for a baby shower cake with fondant icing, which is more resistant to heat.
9. Pick the Filling
Some cakes may have a choice of filling. Options may include icings, puddings, creams, and fruits. Try to pick something that will go well with the taste of both the cake and the icing.
10. Choose Your Greeting.
Some baby shower cakes have room for a custom greeting that is 30 to 50 characters long. Popular baby shower cake messages include
- “Congratulations Mama”
- “Congratulations Mom”
- “Congrats NAME”
- “Welcome baby”
- “Welcome New Arrival”
- “Look out for Mr. Stork!”
- “Our family is growing by 2 feet”
- “Let’s All Cheer, Baby NAME is almost here!”
By following these easy steps, you’ll find it much easier to pick the perfect baby shower cake. Whether you choose to buy one of the inexpensive Walmart baby shower cakes or a fancy cake from an independent bakery, the guest of honor is sure to be delighted with the dessert you pick for the big day.
If you’re buying a baby shower cake, please consider stopping back to tell us about how it went. Let our readers know where you got your cake and how much it cost and give a review to help them choose the best shower cake for their own celebrations.